Monday, April 10, 2017

Quote #10-Feirstein


The distance between insanity and genius is measured only by success
 -Bruce Feirstein 

Sunday, April 9, 2017

Role of Family in Academic Achievement Motivation



The performance of adolescents in school is determined to a large extent by rearing practices they are exposed to in their homes. For example, "It has been found that half to one third of student performance is directly related to home variables" (Chabra, 2011).

Family is the first and major agency of socialization which plays a pivotal role in developing achievement motivation in children. It is well known that motivation plays a large role in student interest and enjoyment in academic contexts. Being appropriately motivated enables individuals to strive for excellence, work and learn effectively, and achieve their potential at school.

Studies have proved that a supportive nurturing environment at home could enhance a child's achievement. According to Lezin, Rollen, Bean, and Taylor (2004), the quality of parent-child relationship has been linked to a wide variety of outcomes including traits (self-confidence, coping skills, motivation, overall well-being), mental health (depression, suicide, identity), risky behaviors (violence, drug and alcohol use), school achievement, and social skills.

Parent's education influences parent's skill, values, and knowledge of the educational system, which in turn influences their educational practices at home. Well-educated parents are more involved in their children's education than less educated parents (Grolnick & Slowiaczek, 1994; Stevenson & Baker, 1997). As a result," the more actively involved parents are in children's education, the higher their children's perceptions of competence and the better they perform in school and enhance their achievement motivation" (Chabra 2011). Students whose parents are more involved in their school life and attend more school activities have higher educational aspirations.      

In one paper on achievement motivation and home environment, Joshi states:
 Parental involvement had a positive influence on adolescents' achievement. The results also subscribe to the view that where parents of high achievers provide good quality home environment, ensuring balance in all its quality dimensions, children get introduced to higher achievement motivation levels. Home environment is a basic and essential nurturing support system for all of us as no other system could be a substitute for multiple bonding provided by family. 
Furthermore, Moula (2010) tried to investigate the relationship between achievement motivation and human environment. He defined the home environment by five factors (parent's encouragement, parent's occupation, parent's education, family size, and learning facilities at home. The findings showed that four factors (parent's occupation, parents' education, family size, and learning facilities) affect achievement motivation positively while only parental encouragement showed unclear results with academic motivation. The reason being is that parental encouragement is usually good but might sometimes result in parents pressuring children which might create anxiety and fear of failure (thus diminishing intrinsic motivation).

However, other studies like Ramiah (1990) observed a different relationship between parental encouragement and academic achievement of students. He found that the more the parental encouragement, the better the academic achievement. For example, Sharma (2002) "studied the effect of parental involvement and aspirations on student's aspirations and academic achievement and found that students with high parental involvement scored higher on educational aspiration as compared to their counterparts with low parental involvement."

Interestingly enough, "family income, education, and occupation are less influential for achievement motivation of adolescents than parental interaction with children, involvement in their children's education and expectation for their children" (Hao and Burns, 1998).    

Additionally, studies by Boon (2007) and Gonzalez and Wolters (2006) found that parents who exhibited an authoritative parenting style (characterized by relationships wherein the child's perspective is acknowledged and respected with appropriate boundaries and rules) had children who were mastery goal orientated.

Finally, "Supportive and caring relationships with parents were found to positively predict greater interest in academic endeavors, higher expectations of success, better self-regulation, as well as increased perceptions of competence" (King,2014).

All in all, a family's social conditions and parenting practices used in raising and teaching children significantly correlate to the child's sense of academic achievement motivation. This includes education, occupation, encouragement, involvement, emotional support, and access to resources which all correspond to teaching children self-regulatory practices to enhance their motivation in school.      

Friday, April 7, 2017

Semajno NaĆ­ (9)



Hello again fascinated - and fascinating - psychology readers! This week I did quite a few statistical analysis tests in order to derive some meaning from all the numbers.

At first, I did a factor analysis on the items of conformity and derived factors that had statistical significance present in the study.

In statistics, underlying correlations between certain items that have a role in the data are called factors. For example, factor one for conformity might indicate being persuaded by others while factor two is the desire to match one's standards to others. All of these factors are a specific indication of something greater happening "behind the scenes" of the numbers and reflect some aspect of conformity.

Here is a picture of the factor rotation that I did when I was looking into potential factors that existed.

factor (2).jpg

This indicates that there are only three factors with an Eigenvalue greater than one. As a result, I checked the component matrix to see which items were associated most strongly with factors 1, 2, and 3.

After that, I did item analyses to see which items correlated most strongly within the factors. In statistics, items are the formal definition of the questions/statements that are answered in the survey by the participants.

The most exciting outcome of these tests was that I was able to narrow down the original 8-item scale to a 4-item scale with two distinct factors that controlled for over 64% of the total variance! Sweet!

The important thing to note is that actually performing a statistical test is simple as the program computes the numbers for you. However, the challenging part is when you attempt to assess all the components of your study and figure out how you are to approach it statistically. Essentially, statistics is easy to do once you know what you are doing and why you are doing it.

Finally, I wanted to see how conformity related to everything else so I did correlation analyses between the factors and all the other variables. This meant having TONS of correlation tests between the conformity factors and each of the other variables (there about 12 sets of variables).

There is much to describe here but its more technical and numerical than what can easily be understood. But I promise it will all be incorporated in my final research paper.

As always, stay motivated and see you next time!

Thursday, April 6, 2017

What is the Self-EfficacyTheory of Achievement Motivation?


In the last informational post, we briefly mentioned that achievement goal theory branches into two predominant approaches: expectancy-value theory and self-efficacy theory. Expectancy-value theory states that individuals are more likely to engage in a particular achievement task when they expect to do well and when the task has some value to them. (This is the scale I am using personally to measure my variables for achievement motivation.) Self-efficacy theory, on the other hand, emphasizes the importance of individual judgments of capability.

Today, I desire to provide a short look into self-efficacy theory and relate it to academic motivation.

Besides cognitive factors, various motivational factors were have been found to be important predictors of first-year academic achievement and study persistence. "In a meta-analysis of psychological correlates of university student's academic performance in general, performance self-efficacy was found to be the strongest correlate, followed by high-school GPA and ACT scores" (Richardson et al 2012).Self-efficacy is similar to psychological self-concept which alongside autonomous motivation has been repeatedly associated with academic achievement.  

Self-efficacy is defined as "People's judgements of their capabilities to organize and execute courses of actions required to attain designated types of performances" (Bandura, 1986, p.391). Much research has clarified the role of self-efficacy as a mechanism underlying behavioral change, maintenance, and generalization. For example, there is evidence that self-efficacy predicts such diverse outcomes as academic achievements, social skills, smoking cessation, pain tolerance, athletic performances, and career choices (Bandura, 1986). Individuals who feel efficacious are hypothesized to work harder and persist longer when difficulties than those who doubt their capabilities.

"Self-efficacy theory postulates that people acquire information to appraise efficacy from their performance accomplishments, vicarious experiences, forms of persuasion, and physiological indexes" (Schunk 2014).  For example, students can acquire positive persuasory feedback which enhances self-efficacy (e.g. "You can do this"), but this feedback will be temporary if subsequent efforts turn out poorly. Students also derive efficacy information from physiological indexes (e.g. heart rate and sweating). Bodily symptoms signalizing anxiety might be interpreted to indicate a lack of skills.  Schunk (1989) discussed how self-efficacy might operate during academic learning.

At the start of an activity, students differ in their beliefs about their capabilities to acquire knowledge, perform skills, master the material so forth. Initial self-efficacy served as a function of aptitude and prior experiences. Such personal factors such as goal setting and information processing, along with situational factors affects students while they are working. Motivation is enhanced when students perceive they are making progress in learning. In turn, as students work on tasks and become more skillful, they maintain a sense of self-efficacy for performing well.
 Expectancy-value theory stresses the notion that behavior is a joint function of people's expectations of a particular outcome of performing a behavior and the extent to which they value those outcomes. (Eccles,1983). However, Self-efficacy theory differs from expectancy-value formulations in its emphasis on student's beliefs concerning their capabilities to learn and effectively employ the skills and knowledge necessary to attain the valued outcomes.

According to multiple assessments and statistical tests, self-efficacy predicts motivational outcomes fairly well. Significant and positive correlations (rs = .38 to .42) have been obtained between self-efficacy for learning assessed before receiving instruction and subsequent rate of problem-solving (Schunk & Hanson, 1985). Shell, Murphy, and Bruning (1989) found that self-efficacy accounted for significant portions of the variability in both reading and writing achievement. Collins (1982) demonstrated that self-efficacy predicts motivation and achievement across levels of student ability. Children identified as high, average, or low in mathematical ability, were classified as high or low in efficacy for solving word problems. In one test, children who were given some problems to solve (some were insolvable) and could rework any they missed. Low- and average-ability students with high efficacy worked on insolvable problems longer than did low-efficacy students. Finally, regardless of ability, students with higher efficacy reworked more problems than did students with lower efficacy.    

All in all, self-efficacy is another model of achievement motivation that is being extensively evaluated and tested alongside achievement goal theory as a predictor of individual success.    

Tuesday, April 4, 2017

Question #9- Happiness


Do you believe that happiness comes later in life once a certain goal is achieved, or is it an actualization that should be thoroughly and consistently sought after?

Monday, April 3, 2017

Quote #9- Oscar Wilde


To live is the rarest thing in the world. Most people exist, that is all.
-Oscar Wilde

Sunday, April 2, 2017

Literature Review: Classroom Structure and Achievement Goals



Hello everyone! Since I have completed my literature review on the required course texts, I will continue my analysis and discussion on other, related psychological articles. Today, I will go through "Classroom, Goal Structure, Student Motivation, and Academic Achievement" by Meece and his colleagues. Their study focused on using an achievement goal framework to examine the influence of classroom and school environments on student's academic motivation and achievement. However, rather than experimenting and publishing a new study, Meece created a synthesis paper to analyze prior research and relate it to an academic context. Let's begin!

The author starts by explaining how education in America has changed significantly over the past 25 years:
 Computer and interactive software are common in most classrooms today, and rows of student desks have been replaced with movable tables and chairs that promote collaborative learning among two or more students. many states and school districts have reduced class size to increase learning opportunities, especially for young or high-risk students. Reform at the middle school level has introduced block scheduling, advisory teams, schools-within schools, and other structural changes to meet the developmental needs of young adolescents (p. 488) 
Alongside this, national councils have called for paradigm shifts in how teachers think about learning and teaching. More modern curriculum standards emerged that emphasized individual inquiry, problem-solving, critical thinking, and collaborative learning rather than focusing on rote learning and memorization. "With the exception of research on class size, little evidence is available to evaluate the effects of various reform efforts of the past 25 years on student learning and motivation"(Meece et al., 2006). Child development research suggests that schools along with the family and peer group, are one of the most influential social contexts for children's development (Eccles, 2004).

 In the paper, an achievement goal framework is adopted for examining the influence of different classroom and school environments on children's development as learners. In particular, the student's motivation and their self-perceptions are emphasized along with their academic engagement.

Meece then provides an extensive overview of Achievement Goal Theory:
Motivational theories focus on the processes that explain goal-directed activity. Generally, motivation theorists are interested in explaining physical activity such as task engagement and persistence, as well as cognitive activities such as problem-solving and decision-making. In educational research, motivation theories are most often used to explain student's activity choice, engagement, persistence, help seeking, and performance in school.    
Motivated behavior has been explained in terms of drives, instincts, motives, and other internal traits (Weiner, 1990). But it has also been rationalized in terms of behavioral associations involving rewards contingencies. "More contemporary theories focus on social-cognitive processes as sources of motivation" (Meece et al, 2006). For example, this approach strives to link achievement to how individuals interpret their success and failures in achievement situations. This led to the development of expectancy-value theory which looks at achievement-related behavior to individual expectancy and value perceptions (Atkinson, 1964; Wigfield & Eccles 1992, 2000). Similarly, the self-efficacy theory of achievement motivation was created to emphasize the importance of individual judgments of capability (Bandura, 1986).

In terms of academic application, "Achievement goal theory has served as an important lens for analyzing the influence of different classroom structures and school environments on student motivation and learning" (Meece et al., 2006). Achievement goal theorists focus specifically on goals involving the development or demonstration of competence (Nicholls 1984). Meece (2006) states:
The distinguishing feature of achievement behavior is its goal of competence or perception of competence, and ability can be defined in several different ways. Thus, the criteria or standards of excellence people use to judge their competence are key to achievement goal theory. This point is critical because classrooms and school environments differ with regards to evaluation standards used to assess students' academic progress and achievement (p. 489).               
The author continues by explaining the differences between the four different goal orientations commonly used in achievement goal theory (mastery-approach, mastery-avoidance, performance-approach, performance-avoidance). I mentioned these in a previous blog post of mine, which you can access here.

Much of achievement goal research indicates that mastery goals are the most effective goals, in terms of their results, as they have been linked to "higher levels of task involvement, persistence at difficult tasks, better learning strategies that enhanced conceptual understanding, and positive perceptions of academic ability" (Meece et al., 2006). However, the expected positive relation between mastery goals and academic performance has not been consistently found.

On the other hand, performance goals also show interesting relations to achievement-related behaviors across studies. A good deal of evidence suggests that they are associated with surface-level learning strategies, which do not necessarily promote conceptual understanding. Also, older research that did not incorporate the performance approach and performance avoidance distinction found some associations between performance goals and self-handicapping strategies (e.g. goofing off, procrastinating, etc.). Therefore, the general consensus is that performance-approach goals are slightly positive, while performance-avoidance goals are linked with maladaptive behaviors like self-handicapping strategies.

Next, the author highlights the importance of classroom goal structures since students' goal behaviors are quite influenced by what the teacher or academic curriculum stresses.
Research focused on the classroom has examined how teachers may create different goals structures in the classrooms through their use of various instructional, evaluation, and grouping strategies (Kaplin et al. 2002). For example, some teachers are known to differ in their use of ability grouping or competitive grading practices, which can increase the salience of performance goals. Other teachers focus on skill development, mastery, and improvement which can lead students to adopt a mastery orientation (p. 492).   
We discussed above how student's personal achievement goals shape their behavior and learning in educational settings. How might classroom goal structures play a role in these processes? Meece (2006)  articulates:
Classroom goal structures are generally viewed as precursors of student's personal goal orientations, which are thought to have a more proximal influence on motivation and achievement patterns. [....] When students perceive their classrooms or schools as emphasizing effort and understanding, they are more likely to adopt mastery-oriented goals. Conversely, students are more likely to adopt performance-orientated goals when they perceive their school environment as focused on competition for grades and social comparisons of ability (p. 495).       
Finally, there is also evidence to suggest that perceptions of classroom goal structure may exert a direct effect on outcome measures as well. "Evidence to date indicates that approximately 5% to 35% of the variation in student's goal structure perceptions is related to classroom differences" (Meece et al., 2006). As a result, student's subjective perception are very critical for understanding achievement-related patterns in the classroom.

To conclude, in the past 25 years, goal theories of achievement have emerged as an important framework for analyzing the influence of learning environments on a range of developmental and learning outcomes. "Much of this research indicates that young people adopt the most positive and an adaptive approach to learning when the school emphasizes learning, understanding, improving skills, and knowledge (Meece et al., 2006). Therefore, classroom goal structures and environments have a very important role. "Evidence suggests that students show the most positive motivation and learning patterns when their school settings emphasize mastery, understanding, and skill development" Meece et al, 2006). Whereas school environments that are focused on demonstrating high ability and competing for grades can increase the academic performance of some students, research suggest that many young people experience diminished motivation under these conditions.